Insights · Guide
Six listing problems we keep finding at small contractors.
Short answer
Search your own business name on Google Maps and on Yelp, then tap every button. The most common problems are a second Google listing nobody manages, a website button that opens the wrong address, different phone numbers on different sites, and plenty of Yelp reviews with almost none on Google. Each one costs you calls, and each one can be fixed by the owner.
Why listings matter more now
Google and AI tools compare what they find about a business in different places. When the name, phone number and website match everywhere, they can be confident it is one business. When they do not match, your reviews get split and customers land in the wrong place.
The six problems
- Two Google listings for one business. Often an old one with a slightly different name. Reviews are split between them, and the old one may have no phone number.
- A website button that goes somewhere else. We have seen listings that open a parked address one letter off from the real one, and one that opened an unrelated company in another state.
- A website link to a site that is down. The listing still sends people to a suspended account or a security warning.
- Different phone numbers. One number on Yelp, another on Google, sometimes a third on the website.
- A Google listing nobody has claimed. It shows a "Claim this business" link, which means the owner cannot fix it or reply to reviews yet.
- Hundreds of Yelp reviews and few or none on Google. Someone searching on Google sees the smaller number.
A ten-minute check
- Search your business name and city on Google Maps. Count the listings that are yours.
- On each one, tap the phone number and the website button. Note where they go.
- Do the same on your Yelp page, including any links inside offers or deals.
- Write down the name, phone number and website shown in each place. They should be identical.
How to fix them
- Claim your Google listing through Google Business Profile. Only the owner can do this.
- Ask Google to merge or remove a duplicate from inside your profile.
- Correct the phone number and website on each listing so they match your site.
- Ask happy customers for a Google review, not only a Yelp review.
When we build a website for a business, we check its Google and Yelp listings the same day and show the owner what we found.
Common questions
Can someone else fix my Google listing for me?
Someone can walk you through it, but the listing has to be claimed by the owner, and only Google can merge duplicates.
Do duplicate listings hurt?
They split your reviews between two listings, and the one a customer finds may be missing your phone number or website.
Do Yelp reviews show up on Google?
No. Google shows its own reviews. A business with hundreds of Yelp reviews can still look new on Google.